General advice "misleading": Productivity Commission

Important note: General advice does not offer the same consumer protection and should not be confused with “personal” advice according to the Productivity Commission who is calling for the term “general advice” to be scrapped. Fund managers, online direct insurance and industry super funds hide behind the “general advice” disclaimer whereas consumers don’t distinguish the difference between general and personal advice. The “best interest duty” only applies to consumers who receive personal advice.
Read an article on this below:
The Productivity Commission is calling for the existing notion of general advice to be scrapped.

In its draft report into competition in the Australian financial system, the Productivity Commission argues the use of the term ‘advice’ should be limited to work undertaken by a professional adviser on behalf of a client.
Consumers are unable to clearly distinguish between the general promotional effort related to products and actual personal advice, the draft report reads. The Commission labelled general advice “misleading” and called for consumer testing of alternative terminology.
“Currently, the terminology of advice requires consumers to intuitively understand that general advice is like marketing; and personal advice is actually tailored to their situation and carries with it some protection against misuse,” the report states.
The Commission also stated that the Future of Financial Advice reforms have contributed to consolidation in the asset management and financial advice markets, meaning that while consumers may be better protected against poor advice they are also being offered a much narrower range of in-house products.
With the exception of wealth management due to the FoFA reforms, the Commission said providers in product markets are using terms and conditions to shift liability to consumers.
It found overwhelming evidence that few consumers read or understand terms and conditions for the products they purchase as they are “too dense, multi-layered, and poorly designed to understand.”
“It would not be hard to conclude that a segment of the financial system is motivated to keep it that way. Financial literacy of the general population is also low. Even when ‘consent’ has been given, there can be a clear lack of understanding of terms and conditions of consent, and the ‘take it or leave it’ nature of many products discourages consumer engagement,” the report reads.
The Commission proposed a new regime under which the obligation to identify appropriate target and non-target markets for products would fall directly on issuers and distributors of products.
“Such a regime should be an approach to financial product disclosure that recognises incentives faced by providers and the realities faced by consumers, and takes advantage of digital data published in real time to show what the market opportunities are,” the report states.
The Commission is also considering recommending to ASIC that financial advisers be able to provide advice on select credit products, namely home loans, personal loans and credit cards. It has called for consultation on the merits of such a proposal; which credit products should be included; the nature of any duty advisers would have to clients; different licensing approaches; and regulatory costs and the impact on the industry.
The Productivity Commission’s final report is expected to be handed down by 1 July 2018.

More Articles

Why crypto treads an uncertain path through tax minefield

The taxation of digital assets used for lending and borrowing would benefit from clear-sighted...

Read full article

Wheat Production by Country

Check out the countries that produce the most...

Read full article

Labor tweaks stage 3 tax cuts to make room for ‘middle Australia’

Following years of mixed messaging, Labor has bowed to economic pressure and announced changes to its stage...

Read full article

Investment and economic outlook, January 2024

Region-by-region economic outlook and latest forecasts for investment returns. . What might shipping...

Read full article

Quarterly reporting regime means communication now paramount: expert

Communication between SMSF trustees, accountants and advisers is more crucial than ever with the quarterly...

Read full article

Four timeless principles for investing success

Investing success can mean different things to different people. Being clear on what success means for you is...

Read full article

Plan now to take advantage of 5-year carry forward rule: expert

This is the last year that the five-year catch-up contribution rules for concessional contributions can be...

Read full article

Super literacy low for cash-strapped

Financial literacy around superannuation is poor for many lower-income people, who still question why they...

Read full article

Sofie Korac is an Authorised Representative (No. 400164) of Prudentia Financial Planning Pty Ltd, AFSL 544118 and a member of the Association of Financial Advisers.

Financial Advice Sydney and the North Shore Office based in Gordon NSW

Financial Services Guide - Disclaimer & Privacy Policy